Top takeaways from the Nonprofit Leadership Impact Study
At the start of this new year, one thing is clear: Rescue Missions are operating in a sector that’s shifting faster than ever. NonProfit PRO’s Nonprofit Leadership Impact Study highlights fundraising trends that many of you are already feeling – shrinking donor files, staffing shortages and evolving technology that can both empower and overwhelm.
But within the trends, the data reveals opportunities Rescue Missions should focus on to build their long-term resilience and expand their impact. Read on for 5 strategic takeaways to help Rescue Missions strengthen their fundraising throughout 2026:
1. Acquisition is the sector’s biggest pain point, but retention is the real opportunity
42% of nonprofit leaders said donor acquisition is their top challenge. Yet only 8% cited donor retention as their primary challenge, despite first-year retention being just 19% in the nonprofit sector.
Key Takeaway for 2026:
Acquisition may dominate the headlines, but donor retention strategies will protect your mission.
Your programs rely on a consistent, loyal donor base. At BDI, we continue to see that Rescue Missions who lean into retention – thoughtful segmentation, meaningful storytelling, consistent multichannel engagement – build stability even when donor counts are shrinking nationwide.
Rescue Mission Resource:
This in-depth article explores how Rescue Missions can better understand their donor personas and use that information to boost retention with their supporters. Read it here.
2. Revenue diversification can no longer wait
Only 16% of nonprofits named revenue diversification a top priority, even after widespread federal grant cuts rattled budgets in 2024-25.
Key Takeaway for 2026:
The report reinforces what many of you experienced this year: a single revenue source is no longer enough. A stable future requires sustainable fundraising strategies including:
- Growing recurring gifts
- Expanding corporate partnerships
- Strengthening mid-level and major donor pipelines
- Building private grants
Diversified revenue is resilience. It creates stability so Rescue Missions can serve more people, even when funding landscapes shift.
Rescue Mission Resource:
At BDI, we encourage our client partners to develop clear communication channels to their “investor donors.” Investor donors are those middle and major donors who most likely are contributing a growing share of an organization’s total revenue.
In a recent article, BDI’s Chief Creative Officer James Read shared how nurturing, shepherding and expanding your audience of investor donors is essential for your organization’s health over the next decade and beyond. You can read his article here for specific tips to champion your middle and major donors.
3. Workforce strain is shaping organizational health
Across the industry, nonprofit teams report:
- 55% struggle to offer competitive compensation
- 54% struggle with overwork and burnout
- 40% cite their biggest obstacle as limited staff capacity to manage volunteers
This reflects what many Rescue Missions experience – high demand for services, lean teams, heavy emotional weight and limited resources.
Key Takeaway for 2026:
Healthy nonprofit teams fuel healthy donor relationships. The reports show that Rescue Missions that invest in hybrid flexibility, smart automation and clear staff role expectations are better positioned to sustain growth and reduce burnout.
Rescue Mission Resource:
BDI’s Senior Director of People and Culture, McKennah Williams, published one of our most popular articles on practical tips to help create a culture of employee appreciation. Read it here.
4. AI and analytics adoption is accelerating, but skills are lagging
The report highlights some striking trends:
- AI adoption jumped to 74% sector-wide in 2024
- Copywriting is the top use case for AI
- Yet 53% of leaders say that staff capacity remains the top barrier to leveraging AI
- 31% say their teams need training to use AI tools effectively
Key Takeaway for 2026:
AI will amplify your impact if your systems and staff are ready for it.
AI isn’t about replacing people, it’s about freeing your people to focus on what they do best. Strategic applications matter more than volume. Start with:
- Automating repetitive tasks
- Copywriting simple communications
- Enhancing personalization in donor journeys
If you are leveraging AI at your Rescue Mission, it’s important to remember that success requires clean data, clear processes and training – not just tools.
Rescue Mission Resource:
If you would like to learn how to better leverage AI in nonprofit fundraising, BDI’s President Mike Rogers wrote this helpful article around the AI revolution that organizations are witnessing today. Read it now.
As part of our shared partnership with the Giving Institute, our friends over at Dunham and Co. shared an article that lists the main AI platforms that nonprofits can leverage today. If you are unsure what tool to try first, this article can be a great place to start.
5. Board engagement remains a persistent challenge
72% of nonprofits struggle to get their boards actively involved in fundraising. This is not new to Rescue Missions, but something that has continued to be a struggle for nonprofit leaders and exacerbated by today’s quickly changing philanthropic environment.
Key Takeaway for 2026:
Board partnership is essential for fundraising success, especially in a shifting donor landscape. Make your board a key part of your 2026 fundraising strategy by:
- Communicating clear giving expectations
- Assigning fundraising roles that match board strengths
- Being consistent in your engagement and communication
Your board can offer a steady foundation for organizational growth, but only if they have an established structure and a clear understanding of your expectations for their involvement.
In Summary: What Matters Most for Rescue Missions in 2026
The data tells a clear story. Rescue Missions that thrive in the year ahead will be the ones that:
1. Lean into deeper donor relationships, not just bigger lists. Building your donors’ trust is key to retention.
2. Build diverse and resilient revenue streams. Sustainers, corporate partners, mid-level and major donors each have a role to play.
3. Care for their teams as intentionally as they care for their donors. A strong internal culture radiates outward into stronger fundraising.
4. Adopt technology thoughtfully, not reactively. The goal is clarity and efficiency, not complexity.
5. Engage their boards as partners in growth. Shared responsibility leads to shared success.
A Final Word
At BDI, we believe the numbers matter – but the people behind them are the true reason for our work. Rescue Missions continue to lead with compassion in the face of rising need, and this report confirms what we see every day: your resilience, creativity and commitment remain unmatched.
As you look to what this new year holds, know that you’re not navigating these challenges alone. We’re here to help you interpret the data, strengthen your strategy and turn every insight into impact.
Because the heart of this work – changed lives – is worth every effort.
Stay updated on what’s next for nonprofit fundraising!
Sign up for our newsletter today to get the fuel that will help boost your fundraising for nonprofits to the next level.
