How Much Is Video Worth in Nonprofit Fundraising? What BDI’s Latest Data Reveals 

From Sarah Wallin, Vice President, Creative Director and Taryn Myers, Director of Digital Media

Every year-end, Rescue Mission leaders decide where their digital dollars go. For many Rescue Missions, video is treated as a nice-to-have, funded after everything else. 

Our data suggests that approach deserves a second look. For Rescue Missions that haven’t fully embraced video in their fundraising, that could mean missing valuable opportunities to connect with donors and inspire giving.  

Video can be a powerful way to tell stories, connect with donors and communicate a mission’s impact. But we wanted to look beyond the creative possibilities and examine the actual fundraising results. 

So, we took a closer look at Meta fundraising campaigns across 30+ Rescue Missions during the final four months of 2025. Among organizations with similar ad budgets, those running video achieved nearly double the return on ad spend, a 33% lower cost per gift and 25% larger average gifts. 

The gap held across every budget tier we examined, and it remained even after we removed the top-performing Rescue Missions using video. 

Here’s what the numbers revealed and what they could mean for your digital fundraising strategy: 

To better understand the relationship between video and fundraising results, BDI reviewed Meta-attributed performance data from September through December 2025. 

Our analysis included 30+ Rescue Missions running fundraising campaigns on Meta, comparing organizations that incorporated video into their campaigns with those that did not. 

We focused on three key performance indicators: 

  1. Return on Ad Spend (ROAS): How much donation revenue was attributed to each dollar spent on advertising. 
  1. Cost Per Gift: How much advertising investment was required for each attributed donation. 
  1. Average Gift Amount: The average value of donations attributed to the campaigns. 

Looking at all eligible fundraising campaigns, the difference was significant. 

Rescue Missions incorporating video achieved approximately 77% higher return on ad spend, with lower costs per gift and larger average donations. 

These results offered an encouraging first look at the relationship between video and fundraising performance. But we wanted to dig deeper. 

After all, organizations with larger advertising budgets may have advantages that extend beyond their creative strategy. 

Does Video Still Perform Better When Budgets Are Similar?   

One of the biggest considerations in evaluating fundraising performance is advertising spend. 

A Rescue Mission investing significantly more in digital advertising may have a different donor base, greater brand recognition or additional resources that influence its results. 

To better understand the impact of video, we narrowed our analysis to Rescue Missions within a specific advertising spend range to see whether the performance gap would remain.  

To explore how advertising spend might influence performance, BDI focused on Rescue Missions spending between $5,000 and $13,000 on Meta advertising during the study period. While budgets varied within this range, narrowing the analysis allowed us to examine whether the performance gap persisted within this spending bracket.  

This group included 22 Rescue Missions: 13 using video and 9 without video.  

Even with similar advertising budgets, the performance gap remained. 

The results at a glance: 

  • Nearly 2x the return on ad spend: Rescue Missions using video achieved 11.8x ROAS compared with 6.1x for those without video. 
  • 33% lower cost per gift: Rescue Missions using video averaged $12 per gift compared with $18. 
  • 25% larger average gifts: Rescue Missions using video received an average gift of $137, compared with $110 for those without video.  

The larger average gift deserves a second look. A higher average gift amount can help Rescue Missions generate more fundraising revenue from their campaigns, making each donor contribution go further. 

When every dollar invested in fundraising matters, stronger returns and lower acquisition costs can help organizations make more of their marketing resources. 

And while these results don’t establish that video alone produced the difference, they suggest that video deserves serious consideration as part of a well-rounded digital fundraising strategy. 

The Results Held Up Across Different Budget Levels  

We also wanted to understand whether the stronger results were concentrated among a handful of organizations or reflected a broader pattern. 

To find out, we divided the Rescue Missions with comparable advertising budgets into three narrower spending groups.

Across all three spending ranges, Rescue Missions using video achieved higher Meta-attributed returns than those without video. 

We took the analysis one step further by comparing each Rescue Mission without video with a Rescue Mission using video that had the closest advertising budget. 

In two out of three head-to-head comparisons (six of nine pairs), Rescue Missions using video achieved higher ROAS. 

Even after excluding the top-performing Rescue Missions using video, the remaining group achieved 9.0x ROAS compared with 6.1x for Rescue Missions without video. 

Together, these comparisons suggest that video can be a valuable part of a digital fundraising strategy across different advertising budgets. Rescue Missions using video consistently demonstrated stronger fundraising performance, reinforcing its potential to help organizations make more of their advertising investments. 

What Does This Mean for Nonprofits?  

These findings point to a clear opportunity for video within a larger, integrated fundraising strategy. For Rescue Missions already investing in digital fundraising, video deserves a planned place in both the strategy and the budget.  

At BDI, we believe successful fundraising starts with understanding donors and building meaningful relationships throughout the giving continuum. Reaching supporters with the right message at the right time helps Rescue Missions create opportunities for deeper engagement and continued giving. Video can play a valuable role in communicating a mission’s impact and connecting with donors throughout that journey.  

Here are three ways Rescue Missions can apply these findings to their digital fundraising strategies.  

1. Give Video a Meaningful Place in Your Digital Strategy 

Whether it’s sharing a personal story, showing the impact of donor generosity or helping supporters understand an urgent need, video can communicate emotion and purpose in ways that static creative may not. 

At BDI, our Storytellers Studios team gathers stories and produces video built for fundraising, bringing creative and performance together from the start.  

Our findings suggest that Rescue Missions incorporating video into their Meta fundraising campaigns are also seeing stronger attributed fundraising results. 

For Rescue Missions already investing in digital fundraising, the findings make a compelling case for prioritizing video as a core part of their campaigns, with measurable potential to strengthen fundraising performance and maximize advertising returns.  

2. Look Beyond Views and Engagement 

A video can generate thousands of views and still leave fundraisers wondering whether it contributed to a boost in giving. 

It’s important to look beyond surface-level engagement metrics to evaluate fundraising performance. 

Our analysis focused on return on ad spend, cost per gift and average gift amount because these measures help connect marketing activity with fundraising outcomes. 

For Rescue Missions, effective video campaigns should inspire meaningful donor action and help build relationships that extend beyond the first gift. Understanding how donors respond to video, whether they give again, increase their support or become monthly partners, can help organizations develop strategies that encourage continued engagement and greater giving over time. 

3. Let Strategy Guide Your Creative Investment 

Not every video, campaign or audience will perform the same way. 

That’s why strategic testing, measurement and ongoing optimization are an essential part of video implementation. 

A strong digital fundraising strategy considers how creative formats work alongside audience targeting, donor relationships, campaign messaging and advertising budgets. 

Our research provides a useful benchmark for considering video’s potential, but each organization should evaluate its own performance to determine where video can make the greatest contribution within their fundraising program. 

The Bigger Opportunity: Smarter, More Connected Fundraising 

So, does video make a difference? 

Across the Rescue Missions included in BDI’s analysis, those using video consistently achieved stronger Meta-attributed fundraising results than those without video, even when comparing similar advertising budgets. These differences held across multiple spending ranges and after excluding the strongest-performing video campaigns. 

The findings make a strong case for investing in video as part of a comprehensive fundraising strategy. The opportunity extends beyond the initial gift. Video can help introduce new donors to a mission’s work, give first-time supporters a reason to stay connected and communicate the ongoing impact of their generosity. 

When video is thoughtfully integrated throughout the donor journey, it can support stronger relationships at every stage, from acquisition and engagement to continued giving. 

At BDI, we help Rescue Missions turn these insights into action through Storytellers Studios. From capturing authentic stories and interviews to producing compelling video content and integrating it into digital fundraising campaigns, we bring together creative storytelling and performance-driven strategies. With flexible offerings ranging from ready-to-use video templates to fully customized productions, along with planned campaigns throughout the year, Storytellers Studios helps Rescue Missions make video a more intentional part of their fundraising strategy.  

Want to know where video fits in your fundraising strategy?  

Connect with BDI to explore how Storytellers Studios can support your Rescue Mission’s goals, whether you’re looking for a simple way to get started with video or a more customized, year-round storytelling approach.  

Stay updated on what’s next for nonprofit fundraising!

Sign up for our newsletter today to get the fuel that will help boost your fundraising for nonprofits to the next level.

  • Sarah Wallin

    Sarah Wallin, Vice President, Creative Director

    With 15 years of nonprofit and Rescue Mission experience, Sarah Wallin, MFA, brings her expertise and imagination to her role as Vice President, Creative Director at BDI. She draws on her background as a college English instructor and a wide range of nonprofit writing work – like Boys and Girls Clubs, Goodwill and Catholic Charities – to shape strategies that connect deeply with donors.

  • Taryn Myers, Director of Digital Media

    Taryn is a marketing and media strategy leader with 25+ years in marketing leadership – most recently in nonprofit direct-response fundraising and revenue growth. She has led multi-channel paid media strategy and optimization for mission-driven organizations across the humanitarian and Rescue Mission space, while also supporting healthcare, education and select for-profit brands. Her client experience includes organizations such as The Salvation Army, Meals on Wheels, Mayo Clinic, K9s for Warriors, Feed the Children, CDC Foundation, Ronald McDonald House Charities and more.

More fuel for more impact.

Let's talk.